Home / Energy / Colorado’s fracking battle goes before state Supreme Court
In this file photograph taken Feb. 24, 2015, an activist waves a placard calling for the ban of fracking during a news conference outside the Colorado Convention Center in Denver as the Oil and Gas Task Force meets inside the facility to put the final touches on recommendations for Colorado Gov. John Hickenlooper to consider in the settlement of disputes over oil and gas well development. The Colorado Supreme Court will hear arguments Wednesday, Dec. 9, 2015, in a high-stakes battle over whether local governments can impose tougher rules on oil and gas producers than the state. (AP Photo/David Zalubowski, File) (David Zalubowski/AP)
In this file photograph taken Feb. 24, 2015, an activist waves a placard calling for the ban of fracking during a news conference outside the Colorado Convention Center in Denver as the Oil and Gas Task Force meets inside the facility to put the final touches on recommendations for Colorado Gov. John Hickenlooper to consider in the settlement of disputes over oil and gas well development. The Colorado Supreme Court will hear arguments Wednesday, Dec. 9, 2015, in a high-stakes battle over whether local governments can impose tougher rules on oil and gas producers than the state. (AP Photo/David Zalubowski, File) (David Zalubowski/AP)

Colorado’s fracking battle goes before state Supreme Court

Fracking, or hydraulic fracturing, helped set off an energy boom in Colorado. It also stirred up a fight over the potential dangers to the environment, public health and property values.

Two cases are before the Supreme Court on Wednesday: a ban on fracking in Longmont and a five-year moratorium in Fort Collins. The oil and gas industry sued both cities and won in the lower courts.

Whatever the Supreme Court decides, it probably won’t be the final word. Fracking critics are also asking voters and state regulators to rein in the oil and gas industry and could take the fight to the Legislature.

Related: Colorado Oil and Gas Conservation Commission hearing testimony regarding new rules

Things to know about the fight:

WHY FRACKING MATTERS:

Fracking injects a high-pressure mix of water, sand and chemicals to break open underground formations. Combined with other drilling techniques, it opened up previously inaccessible oil and gas reserves, boosting Colorado’s economy. The industry says it’s safe, but critics worry about danger to the environment and public health from spills and leaks. Others say around-the-clock noise, lights and fumes from drilling rigs make their homes unlivable as oilfields overlap with growing communities.

THE COURT CASE:

Longmont voters banned fracking inside the city in 2012, and Fort Collins voters approved a five-year moratorium in 2013. The Colorado Oil and Gas Association sued, and lower courts threw out the bans. Both cities appealed, and the Supreme Court will listen to oral arguments on Wednesday.

THE BIG PICTURE:

Oil and gas have traditionally been regulated only by state government in Colorado, but Longmont, Fort Collins and other local governments are challenging that. Energy companies prefer state control — it means they have only one set of rules to worry about, and state law says regulators’ job is to foster energy development, not prevent it.

WHAT’S NEXT:

The Supreme Court probably won’t reach a decision for weeks or months, and even then it might not be a definitive ruling. The justices could send one or both cases back to the lower courts to reconsider. If that happens, the question would wind up before the Supreme Court again sometime later.

OTHER BATTLEFIELDS:

The Supreme Court isn’t the only place Colorado’s fracking war is being fought. The industry is putting up a stiff fight before the Oil and Gas Conservation Commission, the state’s rule-making agency, over proposals to give local governments a consulting role but not veto power on drilling sites. A group called Coloradans for Community Rights wants to put a constitutional amendment on the 2016 ballot that would give local governments the right to regulate oil and gas, which is sure to bring a powerful counter-campaign from the industry. Another group, 350 Colorado, wants the Legislature to replace the Oil and Gas Conservation Commission with two agencies, one to protect residents from the effects of oil and gas and another to encourage renewable energy.

 

This article was written by Dan Elliott from The Associated Press and was legally licensed through the NewsCred publisher network.

3 comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*