Home / Energy / Injection wells spur concerns in Athens County

Injection wells spur concerns in Athens County

COOLVILLE, Ohio — Five months ago, Felicia Mettler had never heard the term injection well. She didn’t know what one was or what it held. She didn’t know what an injection well looked like.

She lives with her husband and children in a wood-frame house in a rural part of Athens County near the Hocking River, and she relishes the relative peace of the countryside.

But like many of her neighbors, the growing number of injection wells in Athens County has caught her attention.

In the first three quarters of 2015, Athens County’s injection wells took more fracking wastewater than wells in any other county in Ohio.

It was the first time that Athens County took the most fracking waste. Almost 93 percent of that waste came from out-of-state oil and gas wells, likely in Pennsylvania or West Virginia.

And even though oil and gas prices are down, both by the barrel and at the pump — causing a slowdown in drilling across the country — Ohio as a whole is on pace to take about 4.7 million more barrels of fracking waste in 2015 than it did in 2014, a Dispatch analysis of state records shows.

In the first three quarters of 2015, Athens County took nearly 3.2 million barrels of fracking waste, more than any other county and about 16 percent of the total fracking waste pumped into Ohio injection wells this year. Almost 3 million barrels of that waste came from fracked wells outside Ohio.

The next closest counties, Tuscarawas and Muskingum, took about 2.2 million barrels and 2 million barrels, respectively.

More than 20 million barrels of fracking waste have been injected into injection wells across the state this year, and if injections continue at that pace, Ohio injection wells will by the end of 2015 have taken more than 4.7 million more barrels of fracking waste this year than they did in 2014.

Eric Heis, a spokesman for the Ohio Department of Natural Resources, said the state believes the injection wells are safe.

“They used to put (oil and gas waste) in evaporation pits, which is just a very bad idea — not just because of the chemicals, but the salt would leak into everything,” Heis said. “And now it’s going thousands of feet below the water table with no leaking, which is always a good thing.”

Related: Taking a stance against fracking waste.

Residents still worry. California has shut down dozens of injection wells over concerns that fracking chemicals might have gotten into drinking-water aquifers. In Oklahoma, injection wells have been linked to earthquakes.

And beyond the environmental threats, Athens County residents say, they worry about safety.

More fracking waste means more brine trucks traveling along the county’s roads.

For many Athens County residents, and for residents in other counties where fracking waste gets dumped, the risks far outweigh the rewards: Unlike fracked wells, injection wells don’t create many jobs.

The Ohio Department of Natural Resources collects fees for the first 500,000 barrels of brine that are pumped into each injection well throughout the state. In the first three quarters of 2015, three wells — two in Tuscarawas County and one in Coshocton County — topped 500,000 barrels. The state collected more than $2.1 million from January through September of this year.

But the counties don’t receive any of that money, Heis said. Instead, Natural Resources uses it in part to pay and train inspectors who oversee both fracked wells and injection wells throughout Ohio. The state has about 50 inspectors who monitor about 200 injection wells and 1,140 fracked wells.

Mettler has written letters to the Department of Natural Resources, raising concerns about water quality and asking for air monitoring. Her neighbors have written similar letters, including some that point to problems in other states.

So far, she said, she has been ignored.

“We absolutely feel like the people in this community, we’re expendable,” she said. “It’s like we don’t matter.”

They have asked the Department of Natural Resources to hold a public hearing to address their concerns. But the department rarely holds such meetings, with one in Athens in 2012. The state held an “open house” in Portage County in 2013. Heis said the 2012 Athens County meeting became contentious.

Even some Athens County residents who say they are in favor of hydraulic fracturing — the controversial technique that oil and gas drillers use to access oil and gas deep underground — are concerned about the volume of fracking waste being injected into their county.

One such person is George Weigly, who lives up the road from a site where one injection well already operates and another is being considered.

“What’s the limit on the number of barrels and pressure you can put on the geology under Troy and Rome townships — right now it’s unlimited, and they just keep dumping and dumping and dumping,” Weigly said.

“Why can’t we put limits on the number of injection wells in a geographic area? The more pressure you put on the geology, the more likely you’re going to have a problem.”


This article was written by Laura Arenschield from The Columbus Dispatch and was legally licensed through the NewsCred publisher network.